While the dissent addresses this case alone, the fact that they issued it may reflect a strong desire to limit the scope of the commerce clause across the board. The scalia opinion concurring with the majority opinion appeals to dozens of precedents over the past 70 years under which the commerce clause was. Many thanks to randy barnett for his thoughtful views below on the relationship between the necessary and proper clause and existing commerce clause doctrine. In new book, scalia and garner attack unprincipled. Antonin scalia has 21 books on goodreads with 11240 ratings. The necessary and proper clause allows congress to do what it deems necessary to accomplish its regulatory objectives. Sebelius might find an answer not necessarily the answer in antonin scalia s and bryan a. Wickard, scalia now says, expanded the commerce clause beyond all reason. The cover of the book features scalia s hand holding a legal text. Neither wickard nor raich demonstrated much respect for the original meaning of the commerce clause, and scalia is of course typically a. Supreme court sidesteps commerce clause, cites tax power. He also analyzes scalias positions on the commerce clause and habeas corpus clause of article i, the take care clause of article ii, the criminal procedural provisions of amendments four through eight, protection of state sovereign immunity in the eleventh amendment, and congresss enforcement power under section 5 of the fourteenth amendment. Justice scalia writes howto read guide for interpreting the law. Scalia changes his mind on key obamacare precedent mother.
So scalia sent a pretty clear message that he still believes the commerce clause imposes some limits on what congress can do. Scalia s rationale for the statement made in his book is that the filburn case expanded the commerce clause beyond all reason. Now, within days of the historic ruling, scalia is releasing a new book in. Antonin scalia, parttime liberal the washington post. Justice scalia s treatment of the wickard case had been far. If the health care mandate goes, the commerce clause might.
In wynn, justice scalia denounced the dcc as a judicial fraud, only to. Wickard, scalia writes, expanded the commerce clause beyond all reason by opining that a farmers cultivation of wheat for his own consumption affected interstate commerce and thus could be regulated under the commerce clause. Reflections of a state tax law by walter hellerstein this paper considers justice scalias substantive views of the restraints that the commerce clause imposes on state taxation. In that 1942 decision, justice scalia writes, the supreme court expanded the commerce clause beyond all reason by ruling that a farmers. Justice scalia s treatment of the wickard case had been far more respectful in his judicial writings. A foreword by justice antonin scalia and speeches by. If scalia was too permissive of cooperative federalism, he was too hostile to the socalled dormant commerce clause, which holds that the constitution makes the. He also analyzes scalia s positions on the commerce clause and habeas corpus clause of article i, the take care clause of article ii, the criminal procedural provisions of amendments four through eight, protection of state sovereign immunity in the eleventh amendment, and congresss enforcement power under section 5 of the fourteenth amendment. In scalias new book, hints of health ruling the new. We always have rejected readings of the commerce clause and the scope of federal power that would permit congress to exercise a police power. Concurring scalia congresss power to regulate activities having a substantial effect on interstate commerce is derived from the commerce clause and the necessary and proper clause. He suggests that scalia displays such a keen interest in defending federalism that he sometimes departs from text and tradition, and reveals that he has disagreed with other justices most often in decisions involving the meaning of the first amendments establishment clause. Justice clarence thomas is a skeptic, and so was justice scalia. The new book is the second joint effort between scalia and garner.
Randys argument is more or less the one justice scalia makes in his concurring opinion in gonzales v. In that 1942 decision, justice scalia writes, the supreme court expanded the commerce clause beyond all reason by ruling that a farmers cultivation of wheat for his own consumption affected. That the substantial effects test in commerce clause doctrine should be read. The commerce clause doesnt mean what liberal jurists and even justice scalia have said it does. Likewise, by including only scalia s opinions on civil rights and liberties, weizer has deprived his readers of scalia s classic concurring or dissenting opinions on separation of powers, the negative commerce clause, and the war on terror, not to mention scalia s questionable dissents strictly limiting congresss enforcement powers under. Discover delightful childrens books with prime book box, a subscription that delivers. What baffled many conservatives was the concurring opinion by one antonin scalia, who sided with big government against a sane interpretation of the commerce clause. In scalias new book, hints of health ruling the new york times. Supreme court sidesteps commerce clause, cites tax power, says obamacare is constitutional written. Antonin scalia may have a new foil on the supreme court in the person of elena kagan. The death of justice antonin scalia deprives the u. My purpose is to examine critically justice scalia s dormant or negative commerce clause analysis of the state tax issues on which he has opined and to draw from that examination some general conclusions about justice scalia s commerce clause jurisprudence.
Scalia and ginsburg drop hints about obamacares fate at the supreme court. Historically, the commerce clause has been one of the most powerful tools that the american people have to impose reasonable regulations on giant corporations and to hold them accountable when they do wrong. But the obamacare case offers scalia a chance to fight the expansion of the commerce clause and in raich, he declined to do just that. In that 1942 decision, justice scalia writes, the supreme court expanded the commerce clause beyond all reason by ruling that a farmers cultivation of wheat for his own consumption affected interstate commerce and thus could be regulated under the commerce clause. Scalia opined that the commerce clause, together with the necessary and proper clause, permitted the regulation. Therefore, in the eyes of the supreme court, the commerce clause gives the federal government license to regulate everything from how much. Scalia changes his tune on wickard and the commerce clause. The clause states that the united states congress shall have power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and. This paper considers justice scalias substantive views of the restraints that the commerce clause imposes on state taxation.
But it seems to me that a succinct answer to justice scalias question is that the commerce clause would not limit congresss ability to regulate broccoli if members of the house and senate were. Scalia s reading of the commerce clause in raich is pretty clear. He also analyzes scalia s positions on the commerce clause and habeas. That was the case where the court ruled, with scalia concurring, that the commerce clause gives congress the power to make it illegal for an individual to grow marijuana for personal medical use even in a state where such use is legal under state law. Justices thomas and scalia have been reliable supporters of big business on the corporate court. The clause states that the united states congress shall have power to regulate commerce with foreign nations, and among the several states, and with the indian tribes. Supreme court for retreating on commerce clause limits established in united. Courts and commentators have tended to discuss each of these three areas of commerce as a separate. The legitimacy of the dormant commerce clause although justice scalia joined justice ginsburgs wynne dissent on the ground that he thought the majority misapplied the dcc precedents, he also wrote separately to express a more profound disagreement with the majority. He also analyzes scalia s positions on the commerce clause and habeas corpus clause of article i, the take care clause of article ii, the criminal procedural provisions. His endorsements of originalism, which requires deciding cases as they would have been decided in 1789, and textualism, which limits judges in what they could consider in interpreting text, caused major changes in the way the supreme court decides cases. Raich, holding that the commerce clause gave congress the.
He also analyzes scalias positions on the commerce clause and habeas corpus clause of article i, the take care. Supreme court of a strict constructionist and a gifted writer who could look at a state tax case concerning the dormant commerce clause and find judicial fraud, incoherence, and ad hocery. Justice scalias treatment of the wickard case had been far more respectful in his judicial writings. Antonin scalias complicated history with the commerce clause. In scalias new book, a 500page disquisition on statutory construction. Antonin scalia was one of the most important, outspoken, and controversial justices in the past century. Intention and the canons of legal interpretation the new.
Justice scalia writes, for instance, that he has little use for a central precedent the obama administration has cited to justify the health care law under the constitutions commerce clause. The doctrine is called the dormant or negative commerce clause, and it divides conservatives. Reading tea leaves on obamacare commentary commerce. Scalia changes his mind on key obamacare precedent. In addition, scalia felt that congress may regulate intrastate activities if doing so is a necessary part of a more general regulation of interstate commerce. The bottom line is that if scalia thinks wickard was wrongly decided, hes almost certain to vote to overturn the mandate. If wickard improperly expanded the commerce clause, as scalia. The four more liberal justices endorsed the laws constitutionality under the commerce clause but also joined with roberts on his tax conclusion, thus upholding the law and sending scalia and. Where neil gorsuch stands on three legal issues that. On scalia s method, whether or not it could have been regulated under the commerce clause, it can be regulated under the necessary and proper clause if part of a more general commerce clause. Lionized by the right and demonized by the left, supreme co. The cynical interpretation of scalia s flipflop is that.
Thomas and scalia, the commerce clause, and the healthcare. This paper considers justice scalia s substantive views of the restraints that the commerce clause imposes on state taxation. In the books preface, he explains referring to himself in the third person that. Scalia is known as one of the courts most conservative justices, but a concurrence he wrote in a 2005 case should give opponents of the healthcare law. Anybody following the legal case against obamacare needs to take this. The art of persuading judges, a guide to lawyers on how to and how not to. The commerce clause describes an enumerated power listed in the united states constitution article i, section 8, clause 3.
Those who are still wondering why chief justice john g. In a dissent today from a denial of certiorari, justices clarence thomas and antonin scalia are criticizing the u. Thomas, scalia hit commerce clause retreat in dissent. Justice scalia writes howto read guide for interpreting.